Saturday - STATE CHAMPIONSHIP - AAA

[Notachance]

Judge 1 - 92 to 88 Calhoun
Judge 2 - 93 to 93
Judge 3 - 95 to 97 Pierce
Judge 4 - 90 to 91 Pierce
Judge 5 - 92 to 92

Now explain how one judge watched a completely different competition that the rest of the panel.  Not by a small margin either.  This judge had a bias and there is no question she was not watching the same completion as the other judges.  ANY QUESTIONS!!!! 

[Notachance]

Also I forgot to mention that out of top 15 teams this judge was not the low score on the panel for any team except PIERCE.  WELL WELL!!!!

[Notachance]

The facts I guess are a conversation stopper!!!!!

[Cheerknowledge]

two out of 3 judges that had different scores though pierce was winner too.

[Cheerymom]

maybe someone from pierce will post a video if they have it

[cheerjudge]

I have three statements and the I am done with this topic:

1. If you add the high and the low back in you get the same result... Calhoun wins by one point.
2. Pierce low judge is from middle to south Ga and their high score was the only north Georgia judge on the panel. So I do not feel there was bias.
3. While high 270's is a great score, there is still 20 something points neither team got so obviously there were some execution problems or we would be looking at scores in the high 290's.

[Cheerymom]

Sure wish I knew where all the judges were from!

[Notachance]

So 4 judges missed it and one genius got it right.  Is that really what you are saying?  Only one judge out of 5 even thought they won!!!  Come on don't justify an error!!!!

[Cheerknowledge]

I have three statements and the I am done with this topic:

1. If you add the high and the low back in you get the same result... Calhoun wins by one point.
2. Pierce low judge is from middle to south Ga and their high score was the only north Georgia judge on the panel. So I do not feel there was bias.
3. While high 270's is a great score, there is still 20 something points neither team got so obviously there were some execution problems or we would be looking at scores in the high 290's.

Couple of good points here.

[Cheerknowledge]

So 4 judges missed it and one genius got it right.  Is that really what you are saying?  Only one judge out of 5 even thought they won!!!  Come on don't justify an error!!!!

Good point - can't justify based on one judge

[cheerjudge]

NotAChance the 88 is just as far away from average as the 97 is.
That is the reason the high and low is dropped... So one judge cannot sway
The results. 

[dawclean]

For someone to say Pierce''s execution of tumbling execution was sub-par is asinine.  I guess that's why we all are not judges but,  if there is anything Pierce excelled in during the season, it was definitely tumbling.  It's over, such a shame.

[Cheerymom]

seriously?
 88-92 is 4 points
 95-97 is 2 points

yes I would have to say that is a bigger difference
 
no matter how you look at it there was NO WAY there was a 4 point difference!!!!! IF YOU WERE THERE AND KNOW ANYTHING ABOUT CHEER AT ALL YOU WOULD BE ABLE TO SEE THAT

[Cheerymom]

For someone to say Pierce''s execution of tumbling execution was sub-par is asinine.  I guess that's why we all are not judges but,  if there is anything Pierce excelled in during the season, it was definitely tumbling.  It's over, such a shame.

AGREE 100%

[Cheerknowledge]

Will someone from pierce release a video??  I mean if we are so confident it is a winner.  I just want a link! hahaha sorry-surely it is floating